Senior Football Best & Fairest
Neville Whitley Medal
- 1936 - Bert Leeson (Fords)
- 1937 - Geofrey Chinden (Guild Scouts)
- 1938 - Ivan Duffield (Sea Scouts)
- 1940 - Ernie Carroll (East Geelong)
- 1941 - Patrick Cahir (North Shore)
- 1941 - Sammy McKee (Geelong West)
- 1945 - William Field (North Geelong)
- *Football is restructured after the passing of former GDFL president Evelyn J. Hurst in 1945. From 1946 the senior competition will be known as the Evelyn Hurst Cup. -
- 1946 - Joe Tucker (GWC & FC)
- 1947 - Reg Wells (Queenscliff)
- 1948 - William “Billie” Gliddon (East Geelong)
- 1949 - Ron Clifford (North Geelong)
- 1950 - Anthony Walsh (Queenscliff)
- 1951 - Geoff Harriott (Newtown & Chiwell)
- 1952 - Keith Wayth (Queenscliff)
- 1953 - Geoff Harriott (Newtown & Chiwell)
- 1954 - Keith Wayth (Queenscliff)
- 1955 - Alan Reid (St Albans)
- 1956 - Vic McDonald (St Mary’s)
- 1957 - Alan Reid (St Albans)
- 1958 - Rod West (North Geelong)
- 1959 - Vic McDonald (St Mary’s)
- 1960 - William “Bill” Allen (Barwon)
- 1960 - Geoff Wilson (Lara)
- 1961 - Ron Sells (St Peters)
- 1962 - Ron Sells (St Peters)
- 1963 - Ron Sells (St Peters)
- 1964 - Lindsay Gross (Newtown & Chilwell)
- NORM ALLEN MEDAL 1965-78 -
- 1965 - Ted Newcomb (St Albans)
- 1966 - Ron Sells (St Peters)
- 1967 - Clive Smith (Barwon)
- 1968 - Phil Stringer (Thomson)
- 1969 - Phil Stringer (Thomson)
- 1970 - Lester Gladman (Thomson)
- 1971 - Barry Eddy (GWC & FC)
- 1972 - Terry Mortimer (Thomson)
- 1973 - Phil Moran (St Peters)
- 1974 - Kevin Dent (North Geelong)
- 1975 - Kevin Dent (North Geelong)
- 1976 - John Fagan (St Joseph’s)
- 1977 - Stephen Jackson (Barwon)
- 1978 - Gordon Hynes (North Shore)
- *Ten clubs breakaway to form the Geelong Football League in 1979. -
- 1979 - Ray Russell (Modewarre)
- 1980 - Trevor Potter (Belmont)
- 1981 - Gerald “Herbie” Mathews (Corio)
- 1982 - Gerald “Herbie” Mathews (Corio)
- 1983 - Brad Firman (St Joseph’s)
- DIVISIONAL ERA 1984-1995 -
- DIVISION 1 MEDAL -
- 1984 - Brad Firman (St Joseph’s)
- 1985 - Graham Hood (Thomson)
- 1986 - Wayne Tyquin (Corio)
- 1987 - Steven White (Anakie)
- 1988 - Alan Clark (Lara)
- 1989 - Geoff Ballars (Anakie)
- 1990 - Troy Renfrey (Bell Post Hill)
- 1991 - Corey Bissett (Anakie)
- DIVISION 2 MEDAL -
- 1984 - Ross Bath (Modewarre)
- 1985 - David Cook (Anakie)
- 1986 - Grant McCance (Modewarre)
- 1987 - Mark Lomas (Eastern Suburbs)
- 1988 - Mario Szponar (Eastern Suburbs)
- 1989 - Alan Woodman (Bannockburn)
- 1990 - Darren Fraser (Thomson)
- 1991 - Darren Rowarth (Leigh Districts)
- 1992 - Matt Kelly (St Leonards)
- 1993 - Dean Gray (St Leonards)
- 1994 - Stuart Scott (Geelong West)
- 1995 - Andrew Harris (Leigh Districts)
- NEVILLE WHITLEY MEDAL 1992-2025 -
- 1992 - 25 votes – Mark Stewart (Corio) Age 19y220d
- 1993 - 24 votes – Stuart Beynon (Bell Post Hill) Age 28y120d
- 1994 - 22 votes – Daryl Jones (North Geelong) Age 32y116d
- 1995 - 21 votes – Michael Bird (Modewarre) Age 29y238d
- 1996 - 30 votes – Tim Gardiner (Thomson) Age ??
- 1997 - 21 votes – Tim Gardiner (Thomson) Age ??
- 1997 - 21 votes – Barry Delaney (Werribee Centrals) Age 28y164d
- 1998 - 24 votes – Daryl Jones (North Geelong) Age 36y116d
- 1999 - 22 votes – Jason Fastuca (Werribee Centrals) Age 22y257d
- 2000 - 30 votes – Ricky O’Toole (Corio) Age 23y93d
- 2001 - 41 votes – Clayton Trotter (Anakie) Age 22y284d
- 2002 - 22 votes – Clayton Trotter (Inverleigh) Age 23y283d
- 2003 - 36 votes – Ricky O’Toole (Corio) Age 26y21d
- 2004 - 41 votes – Jason Fastuca (Werribee Centrals) Age 27y258d
- 2005 - 29 votes – Leigh Hardman (North Geelong) Age 19y130d
- 2006 - 26 votes – Jason Fastuca (Werribee Centrals) Age 29y269d
- 2007 - 31 votes – Haami Williams (Belmont Lions) Age 34y170d
- 2008 - 27 votes – Shaun Lewis (Bell Post Hill) Age 29y30d
- 2009 - 28 votes – Jace Kelly (Inverleigh) Age 21y74d
- 2010 - 24 votes – Ryan Coy (East Geelong) Age 29y144d
- 2011 - 22 votes – Lucas Murphy (East Geelong) Age 34y220d
- 2012 - 24 votes – Luke Forbes (Thomson) Age 29y300d
- 2013 - 24 votes – Shane Tobin (Bell Post Hill) Age 29y30d
- 2014 - 24 votes – Andrew Challis (East Geelong) Age 27y356d
- 2015 - 23 votes – Jamie Pitman (North Geelong) Age 25y353d
- 2016 - 22 votes – Brent MacLeod (Thomson) Age 29y126d
- 2017 - 23 votes – Jak Kennedy-Hunt (Inverleigh) Age 21y107d
- 2018 - 23 votes – Matthew James (Bell Post Hill) Age 29y51d
- 2019 - 26 votes – Reece Holwell (Thomson) Age 35y211d
- 2020 – Season not awarded (COVID-19 shutdown) -
- 2021 - 26 votes – Jack Brauman (Bannockburn) Age 26y100d
- 2022 - 22 votes – Dylan Witney (Bell Post Hill) Age 33y60d
- 2023 - 22 votes – Tim McLennan (East Geelong) Age 20y5d
- 2024 - 22 votes – Joel Bennett (Corio) Age 29y205d
- 2025 - 24 votes – Jack Yates (Bell Post Hill) Age 28y296d