Skip to main content
News

Senior Football: Your club's history of multiple league best and fairest winners


18 November 2026
Written by Alex Tigani

Winning a league best and fairest is a rare achievement.

Winning a second is something only a select few footballers can boast.

Across 150 years of GDFNL history, some of the competition's greatest players have managed to achieve the feat, occasionally at different clubs and in different leagues.

Take a look at the multiple league best and fairest winners who have represented our 12 member clubs.

 

Anakie

Anakie has produced some outstanding individual talent at senior level.

In 1991, Corey Bissett claimed the GDFL Division 1 best and fairest with 18 votes in a season where he also kicked an extraordinary 95 goals.

A decade later, Clayton Trotter polled 36 votes to claim his first Whitley Medal at just 22 years of age. His dominance was reflected in the final count, with the next eligible player, Belmont Lions' Brad Davis, finishing on 18 votes.

Trotter would win his second medal with Inverleigh in 2002.

Even this year, Joshua Mawson added another individual honour to Anakie's history when he claimed The Athlete's Foot MVP Award.

However, only one player is known to have won two league best and fairest awards while representing the Roos.

Noel Robertson claimed consecutive Jarman Cup best and fairest awards in 1960 and 1961, adding to an extraordinary record of nine club best and fairests.

 

Bannockburn

In recent years, one Bannockburn legend has joked that the Tigers rarely receive recognition on Whitley Medal night because the umpires don't award them enough votes.

Interestingly, Jack Brauman remains the club's only Whitley Medal winner, sharing the honour in 2021.

David Stanford (2006 and 2012) and Ashley Perkins (2009) have also brought individual league honours to Bannockburn through the Tansing Medal.

However, the late Alan Woodman holds a particularly remarkable place in the club's history.

Woodman won his first GDFL Division 2 best and fairest as a 19-year-old in 1974.

His football journey subsequently took him to Geelong, Camperdown, Grovedale, St Albans and Winchelsea before he returned to his junior club.

In 1988, 14 years after his first triumph, Woodman claimed another Division 2 league best and fairest.

Few players could boast such a lengthy gap between individual league honours.

 

Bell Post Hill

When Bell Post Hill celebrated its 50th anniversary in August, only three players in club history had won both a senior premiership and a Whitley Medal.

They were Shaun Lewis, Shane Tobin and Jack Yates.

Just 26 days after the club's celebrations, Yates achieved something no other Panther had managed.

He went back-to-back.

After polling 24 votes in 2025, Yates added another 22 in 2026 to become the first Bell Post Hill player to win two Whitley Medals.

 

Belmont Lions

At 34 years of age, Haami Williams famously claimed the 2007 Whitley Medal before guiding Belmont Lions to a fairytale senior premiership.

It was not his first individual league honour.

Eight years earlier, Williams had won the Ballarat Football League's Henderson Medal while representing Sunbury in 1999.

His success at Belmont completed a remarkable double across two different competitions.

Almost two decades later, Williams remains the Lions' only Whitley Medallist and senior premiership coach.

 

Corio

Corio may have secured only one senior premiership, but the Devils have produced an impressive collection of league best and fairest winners.

Gerald 'Herbie' Mathews was among the first to establish that reputation, winning consecutive GDFL honours in 1981 and 1982, less than a decade after the club's formation.

While his 1981 vote tally remains unconfirmed, Mathews polled 23 votes in 1982 to finish ahead of St Joseph's John Fitzgerald (19) and Bell Post Hill's Rob Ferris (18).

More recently, Matt James became a dual Whitley Medallist across two clubs.

After polling 30 votes for Bell Post Hill in 2018, James repeated the achievement with another 30 votes for Corio in 2024.

Remarkably, his second triumph came during a season in which the Devils finished with the wooden spoon.

However, few players in league history can match the remarkable voting record of Ricky O'Toole.

In 2000, O'Toole claimed his first Whitley Medal with 30 votes, finishing ahead of Anakie's Clayton Trotter (26).

Although ineligible in 2001, he still polled 22 votes to finish second on the honourboard.

The following season, he again polled 30 votes, finishing runner-up to Trotter (34).

Then came his extraordinary 2003 campaign.

O'Toole polled an incredible 41 votes to win his second Whitley Medal, comfortably ahead of Werribee Centrals' Jason Fastuca (24) and Bell Post Hill's Adam Wells (23).

He wasn't finished.

O'Toole finished runner-up again in 2004 with 27 votes and in 2005 with 22, narrowly missing out to North Geelong teenager Leigh Hardman (23).

That's an extraordinary 172 votes across six consecutive seasons.

 

East Geelong

East Geelong has produced several Whitley Medallists, although none has managed to claim the honour twice.

However, two club legends have achieved that distinction in the Tansing Medal count.

Dave Peters, the club's games record holder, claimed his first Tansing Medal with 16 votes in 1997 before adding another in 2001.

Andrew Ruiter, who finished runner-up in the 1996 Whitley Medal count, also enjoyed success at reserves level.

He claimed Tansing Medals in 2003 and 2011, an impressive eight years apart.

While the Eagles continue to wait for their first dual Whitley Medallist, both players have secured their places among the club's multiple league award winners.

 

Geelong West

When ruckman Geoff Harriott reflected on his football career, he had every reason to be proud of his individual achievements.

After starring for Richmond's Seconds side in 1950, Harriott won the Evelyn Hurst section best and fairest while representing Geelong West CFC in 1951.

Two years later, he claimed another league honour, this time with Newtown & Chilwell in 1953.

His football journey then took him to Coleraine, where his remarkable run of individual success continued.

Harriott won four Munro Medals in 1959, 1961, 1962 and 1964.

That made him a six-time league best and fairest winner across his distinguished career.

While only one of those honours came at Geelong West, his extraordinary achievements elsewhere make him one of the most decorated former players to have represented the club.

 

Inverleigh

Since returning from recess, Inverleigh has produced three Whitley Medal winners.

Clayton Trotter (2002), Jace Kelly (2009) and Jak Kennedy-Hunt (2017) have each claimed the league's highest individual honour.

Others have come agonisingly close.

James Huybens finished runner-up in 2011, Michael Best placed third in 2019 and Luke Wilson finished second in 2022.

Trotter's 2002 triumph was particularly significant, coming just one year after he claimed the Whitley Medal while representing Anakie.

However, Inverleigh's most recent player to win consecutive league best and fairest awards while representing the club was Graham Smyth.

Smyth claimed back-to-back honours in 1957 and 1958 in the Woolworth Cup, then Geelong's second-tier competition.

 

North Geelong

North Geelong is a club with an extraordinary football history.

Its first premiership side in 1878 featured a teenage Charles Brownlow, while its most recent senior premiership was coached by AFL legend Peter Riccardi.

The Magpies have also produced numerous league best and fairest winners, with two names deserving particular recognition.

Kevin Dent won consecutive GDFL Division 1 best and fairest awards in 1974 and 1975.

Remarkably, he almost completed a hat-trick in 1976, finishing level with St Joseph's John Fagan before losing on a countback.

Two decades later, Daryl 'Sid' Jones established himself as another of North Geelong's great individual performers.

After winning three senior premierships in 1990, 1992 and 1993, Jones finished runner-up in the first two Whitley Medal counts in 1992 and 1993.

He finally broke through in 1994, polling 22 votes to claim his first medal.

Four years later, Jones added another with 24 votes in 1998.

When he received the final three votes of that count, he became the oldest Whitley Medal winner in history at 36 years and 114 days.

It was a fitting achievement for one of the Magpies' most decorated players.

 

Thomson

When Thomson's Tim Gardiner was leading the Whitley Medal count in 1997, there was just one problem.

He was nowhere to be seen.

With Gardiner closing in on a second consecutive triumph, former coach Phil Smyth was required to visit his home and make sure he was ready to celebrate.

Gardiner eventually claimed back-to-back Whitley Medals, polling 30 votes in 1996 and 21 in 1997.

He finished his decorated career as a five-time senior premiership player, five-time club best and fairest winner and dual Whitley Medallist.

However, Gardiner wasn't the first Thomson footballer to achieve consecutive league honours.

Phil Stringer had already claimed back-to-back league best and fairest awards in 1968 and 1969.

Stringer was just 18 when he polled 18 votes in 1968 before following up with 24 votes the next season.

Almost three decades later, Gardiner repeated the feat.

 

Werribee Centrals

There has only been one three-time Whitley Medal winner.

Remarkably, he almost gave football away before claiming his first.

Following the 1998 season, former Werribee VFL utility Jason Fastuca had indicated he wasn't going to play the following year.

Fortunately for Werribee Centrals, he changed his mind.

Like Tim Gardiner, Clayton Trotter and Ricky O'Toole, Fastuca helped lift the standard of the GDFL through his exceptional ability to win the football.

In 1999, he polled 22 votes to claim his first Whitley Medal, narrowly finishing ahead of teammate Shaun Stewart.

Five years later, Fastuca added a second medal with 29 votes in 2004 under playing coach Chris Gilham.

An injury-interrupted 2005 season threatened to halt his momentum.

However, Fastuca returned in dominant fashion in 2006, polling 31 votes to claim his third Whitley Medal.

The next eligible player finished with just 17 votes.

No Werribee Centrals player has won a Whitley Medal since.

 

Winchelsea

Winchelsea has enjoyed its share of individual league success across several competitions.

Stewart Mathieson claimed a Bellarine league best and fairest in 1971, while William Alford (1983), Alan Woodman (1987) and David Mitchell (1991) each received the highest individual honour in the Colac competition.

Woodman's achievement was particularly notable, having previously won a GDFL Division 2 best and fairest with Bannockburn in 1974 before adding another with the Tigers in 1988.

However, Winchelsea is still waiting to celebrate its first Whitley Medallist.

Before the Blues can dream of producing a dual winner, they must first break through for their maiden medal.

Could 2027 finally be the year?

 

Want to discover more about the history of the Whitley Medal?

Explore the remarkable stories of the winners of the league's highest individual honour in our recently published book - click here